Aug 2002

The Guide - Sydney Morning Herald (Australia)
Lowest of the Low
by Greg Borrowman
Build a better mousetrap and the world will beat a path to your door. That famous saying was not true of mousetraps and certainly doesn't apply to the building of subwoofers. Whise, a small technology innovator based in Melbourne, has invented a better subwoofer but can't even get hi-fi stores to buy demonstration models.
One could understand hi-fi dealers being cautious if Whise was a start-up company and its Profunder subwoofer a completely unknown quantity, but Whise has been in the professional audio side of the business for 15 years and uses such world-famous consultants as Neville Thiele, who developed the unique crossover network used in the Profunder 319A. Tomlinson Holman, the man who gave his initials to the THX system used in movie cinemas throughout the world (the "X" stands for experiment) wrote the technical paper explaining how they work.
Explaining how the Profunder works may be one reason dealers are dragging their heels, because it's difficult to explain. Whise uses a new system it invented called Parametric Acoustic Modelling (PAM) to design the enclosures. Whereas the inside of a conventional subwoofer is empty, Profunder subwoofers are filled with complex arrangements of baffles that physically change the acoustic frequency response of the bass driver without affecting its electrical performance. The PAM enclosure allows Whise to extract the maximum acoustic output from the driver, yet at the same time deliver a flat frequency response with extremely low distortion.
They'd also have to explain how the Neville Thiele Method (NTM) crossover operates. Although similar to the well-known Butterworth and Linkwitz-Riley filters, NTM crossovers enable both acoustic summing and accurate phase control over the crossover point. More significantly, the NTM crossover removes unwanted high-frequency signals far more effectively. Conventional subwoofer crossovers have 6--12dB/octave slopes, with a few top-line models offering 24dB/octave. The 319A's NTM network operates at an incredible 100dB/octave.
The 381mm-diameter bass driver hidden inside the 319A is built in Victoria specifically for Whise. It's capable of generating sound pressure levels in excess of 117dB anywhere between 19Hz and 120Hz.
Awesome is the only word that adequately describes the bass that issued from our Profunder 319A review sample. It's not for nothing that Whise warns it will not be responsible for structural damage to homes in which the Profunder is installed. After only a few minutes with the volume control just halfway up we'd managed to rattle a wall hard enough to dislodge a section of skirting. The bass is not only low and loud, it's also wonderfully clean. There is no audible distortion whatsoever, nor is there any output above the pass-band. That's something we've not been able to say about any other subwoofer we've ever auditioned.
Whise's Profunder 319A is so good that it makes existing subwoofers sound feeble by comparison, even those that are much larger and more costly. Which may be the real reason some hi-fi dealers are less than enthusiastic about this impressive newcomer.
*Greg Borrowman is the editor of Australian HI-FI Magazine and a columnist for The Guide, published in the Sydney Morning Herald. This review first appeared in The Guide, Sydney Morning Herald, August 26, 2002. Copyright. Reprinted with permission.
|